I & N's Survivor: All Stars (Season 5)

previous = India next = TBA

I & N's Survivor: All Stars is the fifth season of Bob and Nasty's first series of a Survivor group game on Tengaged. Credit for the season logo goes to Bob for finding the logo for free on the Internet. The season began on Wednesday January 30, 2017 at 9 PM EST. The original tribes were Otok wearing Purple buffs, and Fuerza wearing Yellow buffs. The tribes merged into the Leyandas tribe wearing Magenta buffs on Day 13. The finale was hosted on February 23, 2017. The votes for the winner were read on February 27, 2017 where Pika beat out Josh in a 5-4 vote. Cole was named Player of the Season.

Twists
1. No Hidden Immunity Idols at Camp - Self explanatory.

2. Advantage Island - Two advantages are hidden on the 25 number grid. After each challenge, one person from the losing tribe that was at the challenge will be chosen to visit AI and bring one other person from either tribe with them. The two each get one guess to find one of the advantages, also the people will not be immune at tribal council.

3. Secret Duo - Each person will be paired with someone from the opposite tribe with the goal of making it to the merge together. If both manage to make the merge then they both receive a hidden immunity idol, however if one of them is eliminated pre merge then neither of them get an idol.

4. Bob vs. Nasty - Teams were drafted by Bob and Nasty before the game began in the theme of co-host vs. co-host.

Contestants
This season featured eighteen returning contestants who were the best of the best from the first four seasons of the series.

Episode 1: "#NoSandra'sAllowed"
The eighteen returning castaways were dropped off on a random Caribbean island and were informed that they had been pre-drafted into teams by Bob and Nasty in the spirit of co-host vs. co-host. They were also informed about the existence of Advantage island and the two advantages hidden on the 25 number grid. They also learned that they would be given a duo partner that they would need to make merge with in order to be both given a hidden immunity idol, the catch was that their partner was on the other tribe. The original tribes were:

(Team Bob wearing Purple buffs) - Brandon, Devin, Harry B., Hufus, Jim, Kolby, Luis, Nick and Sam

(Team Nasty wearing Yellow buffs) - Cole, Jacob G., Jacob K., Josh, Kyle, Pika, Renny, Tiffany and Tim

Duo Partners were: Pika and Nick, Cole and Hufus, Tiffany and Sam, Kyle and Devin, Tim and Jim, Renny and Kolby, Jacob G. and Brandon, and Jacob K. and Harry B.

The tribes then competed in the "Survivor Smorgasbord" challenge as it was the first ever challenge in the history of the series and ended up with Team Bob crushing the competition and send Team Nasty to the first tribal council of the season. Over on Advantage Island, Pika found the Immunity Thief advantage which would allow him to steal the immunity necklace from someone after a challenge ended and give it to someone else of his choosing as long as it wasn't himself.

Back at camp, the tribe debated on whom to send home and it was clear that the majority of the tribe wanted to send home a winner to prevent any repeats from occurring. This made Tiffany and Tim the targets as they were the only two winners on the tribe. Tiffany however didn't show up to the challenge and was the more unpredictable player, whereas Tim had friends on the tribe from past games including Pika and Josh. At tribal, Tiffany was voted out 7-2 becoming the first person voted out of the game only receiving the vote of her longtime friend Renny to eliminate Tim.

Episode 2: "Not a True All Star"
After Tiffany's departure Renny just basically gave up hope of making an inroads and just isolated himself from everybody not even wanting to talk to them. At Otok, it became apparent that Sam wasn't pulling his weight since he hadn't even joined the group to play in the challenges.

In the "Survivor Golf" challenge, Team Nasty rebounded to win the challenge in a close match of luck and sent Team Bob to their first tribal of the season. Back at the Otok camp, the tribe was increasingly annoyed at Sam's lack of participation and unanimously decided to eliminate him as a free out despite Brandon also not attending the challenge and being a former winner. At tribal, Sam was unanimously eliminated 9-0 and was shown to be the biggest waste of an All Star spot in Survivor history by becoming the second person voted out of the game.

Episode 3: "You're My Closest Ally"
After Sam's elimination, Team Bob remained united as they looked forward to the next challenge. Meanwhile over on Team Nasty, Renny continued to give everyone the cold shoulder and quickly made himself more of an outsider than he was before.

At the "Absolute Zero Spamming" challenge, Team Bob got their blog closest to zero points and ended up winning immunity for the second time of the season. Over at Advantage Island, Kolby found the Extra Vote advantage giving him the ability to vote twice at any tribal of his choosing up until and including the final 6.

Back at camp, Pika gave his advantage to reaffirm his loyalty with Tim and the two formed a core group with Cole, Jacob G. and Josh, and decided to target Renny as the obvious outsider. At tribal, Renny was eliminated per his prediction in a 7-1 vote making him the third person voted out of the game.

Episode 4: "A Tribe Full of Shitty Ass Past Relationship Alliances"
Back at camp, Team Nasty was unsure of who would go if they lost another challenge as there was no clear outsiders in the group. Though, Jacob K. was worried as he had a lot of bad relationships with some of his tribemates in past games and hoped that wouldn't hinder him moving forward.

At the challenge, Team Bob once again claimed victory with their superior pop culture knowledge in the "Popular Culture Trivia" challenge.

Back at camp, Jacob K. realized that Josh and Tim had a Final 2 deal that existed before the game even started due to their close friendship with one another. Deciding that he wanted them separated, Jacob K. set his sights on Josh as he figured he'd be easier to get votes for. Pika readily agreed to the idea, but the others were uncertain. Tim decided to begin a campaign of revenge against people who wronged him in past games. First on the chopping block was by coincidence Jacob K., and he pointed out several facts about Jacob K.'s gameplay that got the others on edge as he wasn't the Player of the Season in India for no reason.

At tribal, Jacob K. was blindsided in a 5-2 vote over Josh and became the fourth person voted out of the game leaving Pika alone and on the bottom.

Episode 5: "Not All Dogs Go to Heaven"
Back at camp, Pika was concerned as he knew he was now firmly on the bottom below Kyle and didn't know if he'd survive the next vote.

At the challenge, the tribes were told to drop their buffs as they were swapping tribes and Team Bob and Team Nasty would be no more. The new tribes were:

Otok (meaning Island, wearing Purple buffs): Brandon, Devin, Harry B., Jacob G., Kolby, Kyle and Nick

Fuerza (meaning Strength, wearing Yellow buffs): Cole, Hufus, Jim, Josh, Luis, Pika and Tim

In the Puzzle Race challenge, Fuerza ended their losing streak as they blasted Otok only represented by the lone Kyle at the challenge sending them to tribal council.

Back at camp, Kyle and Jacob G. realized that they were on the bottom and looked for any sort of inroad to keep them alive. Kyle was approached by Nick to vote out Kolby as he thought he had too much power in the tribe. Harry B. meanwhile wanted Nick gone for being a strong social threat that could do damage at the merge, and he also decided to test Jacob G.'s loyalty by telling Devin to inform him that the target was Brandon.

At tribal, Nick as blindsided in a 4-2-1 vote and became the fifth person voted out of the game and also the third consecutive India member voted out from both tribes and fourth overall out of five eliminations.

Episode 6: "Talking to a Pile of Tapioca Pudding"
Back at camp, Harry B. elected to bring Jacob G. into the alliance as he followed his orders at the last vote and made a solid five person alliance leaving Kyle out in the cold. Over at Fuerza, Jim was looking to make a move against either Josh or Tim as he knew that both of them were untrustworthy but he couldn't get anyone to help him as they were unwilling to lose their spot in majority. Luis was likewise having similar difficulties, but Hufus managed to join majority as he was united with his duo partner, Cole, and reunited with fellow #TeamChaos member, Josh.

At the challenge, the tribes competed to see how many posts they could make in a 48 hour interval ever half hour. Otok ended up having the best endurance and sent Fuerza to tribal council for the first time after the swap. Cole however, was immune from the vote as he got the most posts for his tribe at the challenge.

At tribal, Jim was unanaimously voted out 6-1 for his attempts to rock the boat and also due to his lack of effort in the challenges. Jim casted his lone vote for Pika because he saw him as a sheep that needed to break free from his shepherds and figured this vote would jumpstart that process.

Episode 7: "I Don't Want 50 Million Idols"
Back at camp, Pika was relieved that the others spared him and were willing to welcome him back, but he was confused as to why he was targeted by Jim. Over at Otok, Kyle desperately tried to get in good with majority, but they weren't budging meaning he'd have to win the challenge to stay alive.

At the "Whose in Charge Here?" challenge, Otok held a commanding lead but collapsed while going for their final challenge victory allowing Fuerza to storm all the way back and win the challenge meaning they'd have to go back to tribal.

At tribal, Kyle couldn't find any inroads and was unanimously voted out 5-1 and continued the trend of India alumni being eliminated as he casted his vote to Brandon for not even trying in the challenges or the game in general.

Episode 8: "A Battle of Wills"
Back at camp, Jacob G. began fearing for his safety as he knew that he was the odd man out if the tribe went back to tribal council again. Over at Fuerza, Luis was still the lone outsider and looked for a way to turn the others against Tim.

At the "All Mighty Sumo Push" challenge, Otok dominated and sent Fuerza back to tribal council. Back at camp, Luis kept trying to rally others against Tim but they firmly believed that they wouldn't have enough votes to take him out at this stage. Plus they figured that they'd need a shield moving forward to take the targets off of themselves. At tribal, Luis was voted out 5-1 becoming the first member of the jury.

Episode 9: "A Game Full of Liars"
Back at camp, the majority alliance debated about whom to turn on if they lost again. Feasibly it could've been any of them as arguments existed that could make any of them the target. The remaining ten members of both tribes were expecting a merge soon, and before the next challenge, it was announced that they had merged on Day 13 into a tribe wearing Magenta buffs.

The duos whom earned hidden immunity idols for reaching the merge were: Brandon and Jacob G., Devin and Josh, and Cole and Hufus.

As is tradition in I & N's Survivor, the first individual immunity challenge was the "Flag Making Challenge". Cole once again reminded everyone how good he was with designs as he clinched his second Flag Making victory in two tries, as he named the tribe Leyandas. At the merge camp, the Otok fivesome had trouble pinpointing one common target as Kolby wanted to go after Josh, while Harry B. wanted to target Pika. Kolby ended up trying to lull Josh into a false sense of safety by giving him his Extra Vote advantage "to hold on to for him", but Josh became suspicious and rallied the Fuerza members to take out Kolby by painting him as Otok's leader.

That night, Kolby was blindsided in a 5-2-1-1-1 vote to become the 2nd member of the jury as Jacob G. mutineered to join his old comrades, Harry B. and Devin voted for Pika, and Hufs and Brandon both self-voted.

Episode 10: "I Don't Know What the Fuck is Happening!"
Back at camp, the Otok members knew they were in a bad position, but Harry B. tried to rally them to stay strong together. Hufus meanwhile came back after missing the vote and still managed to stay close with Cole and Josh and joined the Fuerza side.

At the "Math is King" challenge, Tim earned redemption by winning one of the few challenges he whiffed on winning in Brazil. At camp, the Otok minority tried pulling in Jacob G. and Josh to take out one of the other Fuerza members and Jacob G. seemed readily interested. Not trusting him as far as he could throw him, Devin convinced Josh to tell the other Fuerza members and turn the tables on Jacob G. so as to not only get out an idol but also a snake.

At tribal, Jacob G. was blindsided with an idol in his pocket by a 7-1-1 vote to become the 3rd Member of the Jury. Jacob G. voted for Harry B., and Harry B. voted for Pika.

Episode 11: "The Glue to this Alliance"
Back at camp, Harry B. was upset about being left out of the plan and voiced his concerns to Josh who told him it was because he didn't want Jacob G. finding out and playing his idol. Harry B. understood his position and forgave him for it, but he was still in minority for the time being.

At the "Cards Against Humanity" challenge, Tim claimed his second consecutive immunity victory and got to work on trying to eliminate either Brandon or Harry B.. Josh had other plans however, as he approached Devin and Harry B. with a plan to backdoor Cole whom he believed had an idol. The two outsiders agreed to the plan, and knowing that he needed one more vote, Josh approached Hufus with his idea as he figured he could trust him. However, Hufus didn't want to turn on his duo partner and went to Cole and informed him of the move. Cole wanted to retaliate against Josh, but Hufus convinced him to take out Devin instead as he wouldn't see it coming and was too much of a wildcard to deal with safely as the end of the game approached.

At tribal, Cole played his idol negating the three votes against him from Devin, Harry B. and Josh. In retaliation, Josh played his own idol as he thought Cole was gunning for him. However that was proven false, as Devin was blindsided with his idol still in his pocket making him the fourth member of the jury in a 4-3*-1-0 vote.

Episode 12: "My Revenge Tour"
Back at camp, Harry B. was frustrated as arguably his closest ally Devin was gone and that left him with the practically only good for a vote Brandon. On the other side, Tim became distrustful of Cole since he was unaware of Cole even possessing an idol and looked to blindside him the next chance he got.

At the "Fill in the Blank" challenge, Cole proved he had the fastest hands and best vocabulary as he claimed his second individual immunity win of the season. Back at camp, with Cole immune Tim and Josh both schemed about eliminating Hufus as Josh revealed that Hufus was Cole's duo partner and that he was the one who ratted out the plan to take Cole down. In other news, Brandon suddenly woke up and began scheming with the other members of the tribe to try and make it deeper in the game. This worried a lot of people, and also upset a lot of people as it was the final 7 and he now was just starting to play while they'd been playing since Day 1. Because of this Cole, Hufus and Pika all decided to target Brandon for the vote. Harry B. rejoiced in his ally returning and pulled him into a plan to take out Pika for being a social threat.

At tribal, Hufus felt something in the air and decided to play his idol, which negated two votes against him, but Pika decided at the last minute to switch his vote to Harry B., and left a 2-2 tie between him and Brandon. In the revote, the others decided to reward Pika for actually playing the game and voted out Brandon 4-1 making him the 5th member of the jury. Only Harry B. refused to vote against his ally.

Episode 13: "Oh how I Love when People Fight"
Back at camp, Harry B. now felt truly alone as all of his fellow post swap Otok members were gone and he was on an island in the tribe. But he knew that he could turn this to his advantage if he played his game right.

At the "Memory Lane" challenge, Pika showed off his memory and won his first ever individual challenge during his entire time in the series. Back at camp, Cole and Tim were at each others' throats as they realized that they're were each other's biggest competitors remaining and Harry B. added more fuel to the fire by egging them on. Cole however reminded everyone that they still didn't want any repeat winners.

At tribal, Josh used his Extra Vote advantage to try and help Tim, but it was in vain as everyone else turned on the last remaining winner and voted him out 4-3 to become the 6th member of the jury.

Episode 14: "We Are the Underdogs"
Back at camp, Harry B. celebrated his achievement, then was approached by Josh about making a final 3 deal with Pika since it was obvious that Cole and Hufus were a pair moving forward. Josh even went so far as to make the deal a final 2 with Harry B. to prove to him how serious he was. Harry B. readily jumped at the offer, and Pika agreed to be a part of the planned final 3.

At the "Jigsaw Puzzle Race" challenge, Cole showed everyone how he was the master of puzzles by submitting by far the fastest time on the puzzle winning him his third individual immunity win of the season. At camp, Hufus suddenly dropped in activity and without his extra vote to make any blindsides happen, the others knew who to vote off.

At tribal, Hufus was voted out 4-1 to become the 7th member of the jury as only Cole refused to turn on his duo partner, and Hufus himself self-voted.

Episode 15: "A Position of No Regrets"
Back at camp, Cole figured he'd need to win the rest of the challenges if he was going to have a chance at winning the game now that Hufus was gone.

At the "Fallen comrades" challenge, after enjoying the finale intro made by Nasty the four competed in a tight battle of guessing what clues alluded to their former competitors. In the end the challenge went into overtime when Josh and Pika tied at 10 points each. In the end, Josh outlasted Pika to claim his first immunity win post merge. At tribal, it was a unanimous decision to eliminate Cole in a 3-1 vote making him the 8th member of the jury as he was the biggest physical threat left in the game.

Afterwards the remaining three castaways competed in the "Tower Building Blocks" challenges as they attempted to out last the others with the highest tower. Pika ended up overcoming the odds and won his second individual immunity of the season. Now faced with a tough choice, Pika chose to eliminate Harry B. over Josh as he felt Harry B. had more friends on the jury thanks to the dismantling of the post swap Otok tribe.

At the FTC, both Josh and Pika were accused of being sheep as they tried taking credit for moves that belonged to other players, but the jury was split on who deserved it more: Pika for his more honest and friendly style, or Josh for his more villainous and cutthroat style. In the end Pika won the title of Sole Survivor in a 5-4 vote. Pika earned the jury votes of Luis, Devin, Brandon, Hufus and Cole, while Josh earned the jury votes of Kolby, Jacob G., Tim, and Harry B..